PAYROLL
By Steve Evans
Over the years, I’ve had a lot of calls from brokers who lost a client to a payroll company, or lost one along the way because of that relationship, and now they’re trying to get that client back. At that point, it’s always too late. The relationship didn’t change overnight. In most cases, someone else got involved over time, helping with payroll issues, onboarding gaps, HR questions, or compliance items that weren’t being addressed. They solved, or at least the client felt like they solved, problems the broker didn’t even know existed.
That’s how these transitions happen.
Clients don’t usually leave because of one major issue. They leave because someone else positioned themselves as better able to support their organization in the day-to-day conversations that matter. Your clients are constantly being pitched. New benefits. New HR tools. New payroll platforms. New “all-in-one” solutions that promise to fix everything. These conversations don’t start at renewal. They happen throughout the year, often when something isn’t working the way it should. That’s what creates risk, not because clients are actively looking to replace you, but because someone else is stepping into conversations that should already be happening.
It’s also important to recognize who is driving many of those conversations. HCM and payroll providers are increasingly positioning themselves to own broader HR discussions, including areas that directly touch benefits. When they have visibility into employee data, enrollment activity, and day-to-day HR operations, it naturally creates opportunities for them to expand the relationship. That doesn’t make them wrong, but it does make it important for brokers to stay engaged in those same areas.
At the same time, there’s been a noticeable shift in the market. More brokers are becoming part of these conversations, not just at renewal, but throughout the year. They’re leaning into HR, compliance, and operational discussions because they see where issues actually surface. These are no longer “nice to have” touchpoints. They’re becoming part of what clients expect from a strong trusted advisor.
For brokers who aren’t there yet, this is the gap. These are the conversations you should not only be prepared to speak to but actively look to be part of. It’s one of the most effective ways to strengthen relationships and close a hole that exists in many benefit agencies today.
Spring and summer are natural times to reset that. It gives brokers a reason to re-engage clients in a practical way, focusing on the operational side of HR where issues tend to surface first and where outside vendors often try to gain a foothold. The goal isn’t to bring a new product to the table. It’s to lead better conversations around the areas that actually impact the client’s day-to-day experience.
If you’re looking for where to start, these are some of the most valuable areas to stay involved.
Where things usually start to go sideways: Employee data
Most HR issues don’t start with benefits or compliance. They start with bad data. Employee information is spread across systems, outdated, or inconsistent. Vacation accruals are off, benefit eligibility isn’t always set up correctly, and small discrepancies build over time until something breaks.
We see this constantly during payroll conversions. Missing information, incorrect classifications, outdated employee details, things that may not have caused issues yet, but easily could. It’s never intentional, but no one really looks at it until something forces them to.
That “something” is often what triggers a conversation with another vendor. Helping clients take a step back and clean up employee data is one of the most valuable ways to stay involved. It touches payroll, benefits, reporting, and compliance, and it’s one of the least prioritized areas until there’s a problem.
When data is clean, everything else works better. When it’s not, it creates opportunities for someone else to step in and offer a “fix.”
If you’re only talking benefits at renewal, you’re missing it
If the only time benefits come up is at renewal, there’s a gap. Employees’ needs change throughout the year, and economic pressure shifts what employees actually value. At the same time, your clients are hearing from other providers who are more than willing to step in and “review their benefits strategy.”
Staying engaged mid-year, even with simple conversations around utilization, contributions, or employee feedback, keeps you in that advisory role. It also changes the dynamic. Instead of reacting to outside recommendations, you’re the one helping shape the direction and reinforcing your position as the primary resource.
“Helping clients take a step back and clean up employee data is one of the most valuable ways to stay involved.”
When company policies don’t match how the business actually runs
Most companies don’t ignore their policies; they just stop revisiting them. Over time, what’s written stops matching how the business actually operates. Managers handle things differently, exceptions become the norm, and consistency starts to break down.
A common example is the employee handbook. It may have been put in place a few years ago, but it hasn’t been updated to reflect how the business actually runs today. Policies around time off, sick leave, or day-to-day practices often don’t match reality anymore, especially in a state like California where requirements continue to evolve.
Many brokers already provide access to HR tools like Mineral or similar resources, but those tools only create value if they’re used. Simply bringing up the ability to review and update the handbook can open the door to a meaningful conversation and remind clients of the resources already available to them.
When issues come up, whether it’s a compliance question or an employee situation, that’s often when outside advisors get pulled in. Staying engaged here helps reduce risk, but just as importantly, it reinforces your role in the conversation before someone else gets invited into it.
A lot of problems start at hiring
Hiring is another one of the common points where things start to break down. It happens quickly, sometimes without any structure, and onboarding usually follows the same pattern. Information isn’t always collected the same way, and important details get missed early on.
Most business owners don’t realize how much this matters. Hiring data feeds the benefits administration system, and if it’s off, everything else is too. Eligibility gets set up wrong, which means enrollments get delayed or missed, and you’re fixing it after the fact.
Those gaps don’t stay isolated. They show up in payroll errors, benefit issues, and compliance problems tied to required forms and notices. For brokers, this is a chance to stay involved in a part of the process that directly impacts benefits and employee experience, instead of only engaging after something goes wrong.
Compliance doesn’t just take care of itself
Compliance doesn’t stand still, especially in California. New requirements around training, employee protections, and documentation continue to evolve, and most small businesses aren’t tracking every update. A good example is California’s harassment prevention training. Many employers know they had to do it at some point, but they lose track of when it needs to be completed again or who still needs it.
That creates an opening, not just for mistakes, but for other vendors to step in with compliance-driven solutions. Keeping compliance and training as part of ongoing conversations, without turning it into a legal deep dive, helps clients stay aware and keeps you positioned as a resource. No one expects you to know every regulation, but you can’t let it fall off the radar.
It’s not just the tools; it’s how you use them
At some point, these challenges stop being about effort and start being about systems. Clients are often using a mix of payroll platforms, benefits systems, and manual HR processes that don’t fully connect. When that happens, even simple tasks become more complicated than they should be.
That’s usually when they start listening to pitches about “better technology.” But the real issue isn’t always the system itself. It’s how everything works together, how data flows between platforms, and how responsive the support is when something goes wrong.
This is also where brokers need to think about the client experience. Many brokers use systems like Employee Navigator, and it can be a great tool, but is it always the best fit? Sometimes it’s more convenient for the broker, while the client ends up with another login and another system to manage. Not every client wants that.
In some cases, recognizing that a client may be better off with a single platform that brings everything together positions you as an advisor who is focused on what’s best for the employer, not just what’s easiest for you to manage. The right answer isn’t always adding something new but also making sure what they have now works as it should.
Staying engaged in those conversations, instead of only reacting when a client is considering a change, gives you a chance to focus on what’s actually best for the client. That’s what ultimately keeps the relationship intact.
Staying in front of it
The common thread through all of this is simple. These conversations can’t just happen at renewal or when something goes wrong. They need to happen throughout the year.
It doesn’t require a formal program or a new process. It’s about being intentional with the conversations you’re already having. Using natural touchpoints to bring up areas that tend to get overlooked, connecting what you’re seeing across other clients, and helping identify small issues before they turn into bigger ones.
That’s what keeps you relevant. And more importantly, it’s what keeps you in the role your clients already expect you to play.
Click here for a direct conversation about alignment, services, and book protection strategies.
Steve Evans is the Co-founder of Premier HCM with over 25 years of payroll sales and leadership experience, and he launched the company to elevate service in an industry that too often forgets what real support looks like. He partners with small to mid-sized businesses that want more than just software, delivering proactive guidance, clear answers, and a deep understanding of client needs through an integrated platform for payroll, HR, time, onboarding, and benefits backed by hands-on service from seasoned professionals. Evans believes strong relationships and practical solutions matter as much as technology and is passionate about helping organizations simplify payroll, improve compliance, and build lasting partnerships.
Featured in our May 2026 Issue page 18 – Click here to download!