BRANDING
By Sarah Dupree, Owner of Echo and Stone
As we begin a new year, you may find yourself inevitably asking the same question, “How do I up my game to get more leads this year?” For most, the instinctive response is buying a new CRM, launching more social media posts, running ads, or purchasing leads. And while these things can help, they rarely contribute to true growth because they don’t fix the real issue.
Most agents don’t have a marketing problem—aka “If I was seen more, I’d have more leads”
The truth is that it’s a branding problem.
It’s not the number of leads or posts on social media. It’s not the volume of your outreach. It’s the lack of clear messaging that instantly creates trust the moment people discover you. More often than not, your brand is building that trust well before you even get a chance to speak to a potential client.
In other words, if your brand is confusing, no amount of marketing can compensate for it.
The Hidden Reality
Insurance is a relationship-driven industry. Potential clients want to feel safe, seen, and understood. So, when your website sounds generic or your social media tone doesn’t match your emails or claiming to serve “everyone,” prospects immediately can sense that something is off. Even if they can’t explain why.
They feel a disconnect between who you say you are and how you show up. Maybe your website sounds formal, but your social content is casual. Or your emails feel warm, but your website reads like it belongs to a different agent altogether. These subtle shifts create doubt, and doubt is all it takes for someone to choose another agent who feels more aligned and reliable.
Humans are wired to avoid inconsistency. In a trust-based field, like insurance, small inconsistencies don’t feel minor. They feel risky. And potential clients don’t want to take risks with someone who will manage their health, life or financial future.
Skip the foundation and pay for it later
Most agents jump straight into marketing because it feels productive. It’s an action that will lead to a predictable outcome, supposedly.
New logo? Feels like growth.
New CRM? Feels like progress.
New ad campaign? Feels like momentum.
But without clearly knowing who you actually serve, what you bring to the table that is special, and why you are a better choice than the competition, all those marketing efforts are being built on sand.
Have you ever experienced the following cycle:
- Launch a new marketing tactic
- See little to no change
- Feel discourage
- Try something else, a different marketing tactic
- Give up until the same time next year and try again
But the problem was never the tools. Or the platform. Or the leads. It’s the foundation beneath them.
Before you market anything
If you want more leads in 2026, start by tightening your brand, not your marketing. Most brands skip this step because branding feels abstract while marketing feels actionable. Branding requires you to slow down. Marketing lets you speed up and do something. But growth only happens when the two work together.
” More leads aren’t the answer. When your brand is clear, consistent, and trustworthy, every marketing effort becomes more effective. You won’t just increase your leads—you will increase the right leads.”
Here are four foundational elements every insurance agent needs in place before investing a single dollar into lead generation:
1. A Clear and Narrow Target Audience
Serving everyone is the fastest way to serving no one.
People don’t trust generalists. They trust people who understand their specific situation. So instead of:
“I help you with life and health insurance”
Try:
“I help self-employed professionals simplify health coverage and avoid expensive mistakes.”
Or
“I work with families who want a simple, practical life insurance strategy that grows with them.”
Specificity attracts. Generality repels.
2. A Consistent Message Across Every Platform
Your website, social media, email, voicemail, and even your business card should feel like they were created by the same person.
When you’re consistent, potential clients think:
“They are stable and trustworthy.”
When you are inconsistent, they subconsciously think:
“If they’re not organized here, what else might they miss?”
And while we’re at it, ditch the industry jargon. It may feel professional, but often potential clients don’t understand half of what you said. Use plain English that connects to real people by speaking how they speak.
3. A Simple, Compelling Value Proposition
Most agents talk about the product, not the problem they solve.
Consumers don’t buy insurance.
What?
Yes, that is what we said, they don’t buy insurance. They buy peace of mind. Protection. Confidence that someone will help them avoid costly mistakes.
A strong value proposition explains:
- The problem you solve
- The people you solve it for
- The outcome they can expect
4. A Trust-Building Digital Presence
Before anyone calls you, they will inevitably Google you. It is 2026 and information is easily accessible.
If the first impression is unclear, outdated or generic, leads fall apart before you even get a chance to begin.
Trust-building elements include:
- Testimonials, stories and reviews from real clients
- Clear homepage messaging
- A professional photo
- Easy to understand explanations of services
- Visible call-to-action
- Consistent brand voice
These little pieces lead to big confidence.
When your brand is Right, Lead Generation Works Effortlessly
The irony is when your positioning is clear and consistent, you actually need less marketing, not more.
- Your ads perform better because they are targeted.
- Your referrals increase because people know exactly who to send you.
- Your content resonates because it sounds like it was written for a specific person.
- Prospects convert faster because they trust you sooner.
Brand clarity lowers your cost per lead and increases your close rate. Confusion does the opposite.
How to Up Your Game in 2026
If you want this year to start different, begin here:
- Identify your niche
Choose a segment you understand and enjoy serving. - Audit your digital presence
Is it consistent everywhere? - Simplify your message
Make it easy for people to know what you do and who you help. - Then (and only then) choose your marketing tactics
Once the foundation is solid, your marketing becomes an amplifier instead of a Band-Aid.
More leads aren’t the answer. When your brand is clear, consistent, and trustworthy, every marketing effort becomes more effective. You won’t just increase your leads—you will increase the right leads.
And that is how you truly up your game in the new year.
As co-founder of Echo & Stone, Sarah Dupree blends brand insight with the empathy of someone who’s built a business from the ground up. After working with brands like Toyota, Boot Barn, and Yamaha, she found a passion for helping female founders see who they really are and empowering them to show up with purpose. To find out more about Echo & Stone’s brand focused approach to marketing, visit www.echostonemedia.com
Featured in our January Special Issue 2026 page 40 – Click here to download!
Sources: